Obviously there are different factors to think about, but generally speaking I would take an Ogre over FG for a Zerk - compare the regenerative abilities of an Ogre Zerk (I consistently would be able to sleep for around 450hp per tick near death with an Ogre) with that of an FG Zerk - that regenerative ability gives you a MASSIVE edge. Ogres still have the ability to have a high damage output too. I'd take high damage output and regen over ultra-high damage output and poorer regen. Then there are the other benefits of higher dex and huge HP base. As always, communers can have their way with the Ogre if the Ogre doesn't have saves (not so much casters, as Zerks are great at tearing up casters, especially invokers, like you've never seen).
Beer: Zerks are not 'fine as it' Post up why you think this. They look strong but in practice their sklils have been chipped and chipped away at over time. They lose rage vs certain classes when they need it most. They get owned by any character with any kind of decent melee ability. No other class has such a hard vs so much of the pbase.
Exactly, I agree 100%.
Of course a Berserker can be powerful in the right hands. If you want an example of a Berserker in more recent times that did well, do a 'record bazin' (Mindflayer's Dwarf Zerk) when in-game. From what I know, he raised the hairs on Suunmar's back more than a few times.
Nobody is saying that a Berserker is too weak to be able to compete, just that there are thoughts from some of the people who have played them a fair bit that in some respects, they are slightly unbalanced - it's a survival struggle playing a Zerk at pinn - think of a Zerk like a doublebladed sword. Destroy some, get destroyed by others.
If a player can kill well and consistently with a class (Zerk) yet could kill so much more efficiently and with less effort with the majority of other classes (assuming we're talking about a player that has equal knowledge of playing all classes), then that doesn't mean Zerks are fine. It means there's a decent player who's having to put in that 110% to get the results he could a lot easier with something else, and that's what makes an otherwise fun class, frustrating.
Dey
EDIT: Crapload of errors edited out. Note to self, don't post first thing in a morning at work when you have hangover.