...that's what we're working towards kind of. It's to help people who want to play a rogue character, or just don't want to be in a cabal. Yes an uncaballed person isn't going to automatically die to a caballed but it is a more uphill battle especially at higher ranks in the cabal. How many times have you fought someone and won until they got that next rank and then had they tore you a new one? We want to make it so that people who aren't in a cabal don't have such different in power.
Yes, a cabaled person should have benefits. But cabals aren't all about power, they're meant to be an extension of your RP, not just another weapon in PK. So I don't see any harm in beefing up an uncabaled somewhat.