As it is now(if I understand correctly), an evil cleric or Dk isn't able to benefit from the kill when they capture a criminal. How about making it so that if an evil cleric or Dk is in the presence of the criminal during the execution, a cleric counts the kill while a DK at the last moment uses his weapon to withdraw the criminals soul into his weapon?
DKs and Evil clerics in Tribunal?
Irumeru had, in the past, been intending to implement just such a thing, although the 'worth' would be level dependent (ie, capturing a level 10 wouldn't give you as much benefit as capturing a level 50, obviously), and subject to the same restrictions of multikilling/capturing (ie, capturing and executing the same criminal twice in a row won't help).
I generally would approve.
How come when I suggest this, I get a sarcastic response along the lines of "Sometimes there are consequences for the path you choose.":p
Wasnt it Malch who said this ?
Anyway, i do not think DK's should have it.
They did not kill them. They chose to capture them alive so that someone else would be the executor. And their opponent can still be freed from prison.
Nothing prevents them from killing non wanted outside the city walls.
Clerics the same thing. And the benefit you get from killing with clerics is not that ....
Imagine a dark knight adjucator.. hell bent on forcing all the inhabitants of Aabahran to seek the walls of protected cities. Those that ignored his warnings were found hanging, beheaded and upside down outside of the city limits.
Imagine a dk adjudicator (trusted) with full malforms and an extra bashing cabal charmie. drools
And then imagine that DK getting assassinated over, and over, and over again.
Doubt it, Evangelion. Not if that DK has one lick of sense.
Wasnt it Malch who said this ?
Yeah, it is pretty much official now. The Queen of Misinformation has been crowned.
The Queen of Misinformation has been crowned.
Not until NOW?! What took so long? 
I am against DKs/Clerics getting ANY benefits from executing a criminal outside their PK range. Even if it is completely minute, it gives too much of a bonus to the class for their cabal choice, especially a cabal with strong powers already.
I personally, don't think they should benefit from this at all. Though I am probably a minority in this.
Correct me if I am wrong, but aren't Outlaws killed outright and not taken to jail anyway? It would just be a reason to outlaw more people and get more enemies... Something that an evil Cleric/DK should be doing regardless.
Outlaws are taken to jail first and then executed.
Outlaws are taken to jail first and then executed.
This isnt mandated.
They may be killed as they recieve ZERO protection from the law. That includes a trial/prison penalty.
O ok, I was always put in prison first.
But doesn't the code do it automatically? I don't think there is a way not to capture an outlaw as a trib.
Release your guard when they are near dead maybe? I dunno honestly, i've only ever had a lowbie Justice back in the day.
This isnt mandated.
They may be killed as they recieve ZERO protection from the law. That includes a trial/prison penalty.
Eh? Never seen that happen. Something other than a guard/tribunal must have killed them then. On my outlaws I always get 12 hours in prison before execution.
An outlaw will be put to jail unless the tribune assassinates him. Then he will simply be dead. DOH. 