I have killed Thulgan. ( i havent read the Syl log...did he try call lightning? Did he have lvll52+ dispels? )
I have not even scratched Anamus.
I've killed warriors decked like that with a battlemage before too. And an Invoker
In terms of warriors though....a warrior, due to weapon choice, should have the damage advantage in almost any fight. It comes down to attrition gaming and chasing in most cases for them.
Non-neutral mages who face someone with a magic resistance or high-lvl saves is going to have a hard(er) time, as they should. But if they have +spell lvl, good tactics, and even curatives...they have an equal chance at winning.
It balances out though. People decked in saves suffer in melee fights, and vice versa. The equipment "balance" in my opinion is fine...you just need to dress appropriately for your enemies. It is the amount of this eq that is hurting everyone.
Players like Thulgan or Anamus or Sepahoona who are decked out of the ears and do not play very often have this great eq and are almost invincible....you can't create a character and get all the necessary eq you need to compete with them, let alone defeat them these days.
Maybe I need to start full looting the "great" people I kill. I never looted Thulgan or Grum (that I can remember, anyway...and if I did it was maybe 1 piece) but I've been full looted by at least one of these people.
Making it harder for me or anyone else in that situation to get back on their feet, or even feel motivated to try.
Rare circulation IS a problem folks. Don't care what numbers are in play or how much they've been changed. Once 2-4 (ogre war, drow cleric, dwarf cleric, drow shaman) people get megadecked and hardly play.....people cannot get decked enough to compete. They get discouraged because the stuff they want isn't in.
I remember back in the day I could log in and Adeptus would have 2-3 pieces a lot of times. I haven't seen him have more than 1 piece in the past year. ARMOR, not weapon. I remember making one trip to Adeptus and he had everything